
This is to be cross posted to my Dreamwidth, LiveJournal and FaceBook accounts.
I realize there are people who will see this title and read no further. So be it. I cannot speak to anyone who chooses not to listen.
I preface this with notice I’m a retired physician, residency trained in the University of California system in Family and Community Medicine. I was board certified in Family Practice. I spent 35 years working predominantly with immigrants, at times serving families that spanned 4 and occasionally 5 generations. Some family units in my practice were as large as 70 family members. Why is that important? It gave me clarity just how interconnected family and community units are for disease clusters, both for contagious and non-contagious conditions.
Poverty affects not only access to health care, but access to healthier food and lifestyles. It is not an accident that hypertension, dyslipidemia, diabetes, heart disease and obesity are rampant within poorer communities. It is a point easily argued that any economic, social or political system that keeps people from climbing into a higher socio-economic class, dooms them to remain in poverty and more often than not, dying at an earlier age of diseases that could have been delayed, if not prevented altogether. I believe this has been fostered by much of the Republican Party in power, but that is not the point of this essay either.
I am talking directly at this point of the president’s current behavior that puts anyone in his immediate vicinity at risk for contracting Covid-19. It appears to be the culmination of his denial of the scientific, medical & epidemiological information he has been given over the past 10 months, and his refusal to accept it, let alone abide by it.
I remain gob smacked that face masks have been made a political issue. I defy ANYONE on the far right, to tell me they would be comfortable undergoing surgery where the surgeon or anyone on the operating room team refused to wear a face mask. Those face masks are predominantly for the protection of the patient. Since the bulk of people who have spread Covid-19 are either asymptomatic or pre-symptomatic, mask wearing by people who feel perfectly well, is to prevent the ones who don’t yet know they are infected and contagious from spreading this disease. Yes, you have a modicum of personal protection afforded by your own mask, especially if it is a properly fitted N-95, but the main reason face masks limit the spread of Covid-19, is to stop infected people from infecting others. FULL STOP. I repeat, it’s to stop symptomless infected people from infecting others.
Instead of sharing the message that masks are crucial to prevent disease spread and modeling that behavior to the American public, the president has undermined that message from the get-go, along with any meaningful modeling of social distancing, which brings us to the present and my main point. Cramming people into tight spaces, even out of doors, and simultaneously discouraging use of face masks are exactly the circumstances that cause what epidemiologists label super-spreader events. This applies to Trump’s pre-debate preparation (likely why former Gov. Christie wound up hospitalized with Covid), to the Rose Garden presentation of Amy Coney Barrett to a throng of political dignitaries sitting shoulder to shoulder, and to Trump’s donor appearance at Bedminster after the presidential debate, and after his close aide and advisor Hope Hicks had been diagnosed with Covid infection and the entire White House staff should have been quarantining. Even the debate put people at unnecessary risk for infection. The Trump entourage after arriving too late for onsite viral testing, entered the venue, sat and then each removed their masks. The hubris flabbergasts me.
Trump was hospitalized after being short of breath, febrile and hypoxic at the White House. He was given early on a large number of Covid treatments, some experimental and many of them simply not available to most of the American public as soon after diagnosis as he was given them, if available at all at any point, given much of the public’s access to state of the art care. Note that Covid death rates have been significantly higher at public and rural hospitals, than at University institutions where the staff to patient ratio is significantly lower. We must recognize the President was been given the VIP treatment, something 95% of the population, if not more, will never be able to receive, and even for those that get it, not with the speed the President did.
What did the President do in the wake of his hospitalization? A photo op from a sealed limousine the day after his hospitalization, putting two Secret Service members in the vehicle with him at unnecessary risk. Even masked, I wouldn’t be willing to enter a closed vehicle, in close quarters with a patient newly diagnosed with Covid. I know of too many health care workers who have died from Covid contracted in the confines of the hospital. There is evidence that the size of the initial dose of virus when you first get infected may significantly affect your outcome. Secret Service members are alleged to be willing to take a bullet for the President; apparently for some it could mean they were willing to get infected for him as well, for a photo op.
However, even more disturbing behaviour came with his return to the White House. Hours after Trump tweeted, “…. Feeling really good! Don’t be afraid of Covid. Don’t let it dominate your life. We have developed, under the Trump Administration, some really great drugs & knowledge. I feel better than I did 20 years ago!”, Trump climbed the stairs to the White House balcony by himself, and at the top of the stairs, somewhat breathless, and on camera for the entire country to see, he removed his mask and only then entered the White House. If he felt better than he had in 20 years, why did a single flight of stairs leave him visibly short of breath? Moreover, he was actively infected and supposed to isolate from others until he no longer infectious. Was there no one else inside the White House? Was there no one inside those walls not already infected?
“…Don’t be afraid of Covid. Don’t let it dominate your life….” The cavalier recklessness of this offends me. According to a former director of the CDC, Covid-19, a disease that did not exist a year ago, is currently the 3rd leading cause of death in the US, after Heart Disease and Cancer. 220,000 Americans are known to have died of Covid in the past 9 months, and the death rate for the same period is up almost 300,000 from the year prior, which forces me to question how many people died secondary to undiagnosed Covid. On average, 1,000 Americans die of this daily. Further, these statistics say nothing about what long-term or permanent consequences survivors may have. Covid has touched my family. Both my siblings, also healthcare providers have had it. There are at least 8 in my extended family who have survived it. Someone I know personally, 20 years my junior, appears to have some heart problems secondary to the infection, now 5 months on.
What we have seen from the president is a total disregard for anyone other than himself. He has by example put way too many Americans at risk, and in the past month, super-spreader events tied to this White House directly, have resulted in more cases of Covid than in New Zealand, Viet Nam and Singapore combined, for the same time period.
What harm is done by wearing a mask? What harm is done by protecting the vulnerable? Yes, a face mask is often not the most comfortable thing to wear, but watching a neighbor, a colleague, a friend, a loved one, ill, hungry for air & gasping for breath is much more uncomfortable. So is the guilt of finding out you were likely responsible for spreading that illness to them.
This simple request, that all of us mask up whenever we are out in public and maintain an adequate social distance is for each other’s safety. This current sense of American exceptionalism, that it’s “my body, my choice”, isn’t defending your right to choose whether you take risks with your own health or not. It’s defending your misguided right to be Typhoid Mary, your right to put the health of others in your immediate vicinity at risk. If all of us recognize that, the choice to mask up is clear, and each of us needs to treat others who choose not to wear a mask in public as the pariahs they are, just as in California the bulk of the populace recognizes that someone smoking in your immediate space is infringing on your right to clean and safe air.
The Kansas legislature has created a rather dramatic experiment. Their governor, a Democrat, imposed a state-wide mandatory mask requirement for everyone when out in public and the legislature, controlled by Republicans, rolled back her authority to so. It has resulted in some counties having the mandate and others not. Roughly two months after this went into effect, the rate of Covid infections in the counties observing the mask mandate is half of what it is in the counties where the mandate is not in effect. Half.
It grieves me more than I can express, that a concern for public safety and for the public's health was made into a political issue. Wearing a face mask should never have been a mark of one's political party. Keeping one another safe, and keeping the resource of our already overburdened hospitals from becoming overwhelmed should have been a uniting message for every single American in this country. We were able to pull together in the face of warfare in both the First and Second World Wars. We all stepped up here at home to protect our American society from a threat from abroad. We rolled up our sleeves as one country. Yet this time, instead of trying to address something that was an existential threat for so many in our midst, we have failed. We have fallen into partisan bickering and politicized something that should have remained apolitical.
As a result, our current death toll from Covid-19 is more or less 300,000, and half of that could probably been prevented.
.